We’re heading to the Maine Supreme Judicial Court in our fight to uphold the right to counsel for people who cannot afford their own attorney in our case Robbins v. State of Maine.

Earlier this year, we won an order from the trial court requiring the state to provide attorneys and establish a plan to end this ongoing crisis – but the state appealed, putting solutions on hold. The Constitution requires states to provide attorneys to people who have been charged with a crime and cannot afford their own, but Maine has been failing to meet that obligation for years.

Watch the arguments live on Tuesday, October 7, at 10 a.m. You can also attend the arguments in person at Upper Kennebec Valley High School in Bingham. (Since 2005, the Law Court has held many arguments at high schools around the state so students and communities throughout Maine can see how the court works up close. Learn more about the court's High School Sessions here.)

Learn more about Robbins v. State of Maine here.

Event Date

Tuesday, October 7, 2025 - 10:00am to
11:00am

Featured image

More information / register

Venue

Live Stream or Upper Kennebec Valley High School

Address

110 Meadow St.
Bingham, ME 04920
United States

Tweet Text

[node:title]

Date

Tuesday, October 7, 2025 - 11:00am

Menu parent dynamic listing

A federal court ordered our client released, finding the government had unlawfully jailed him and denied him a bond hearing – a blatant violation of federal law.

We have an important update on our recent victory in federal court.

A federal judge ordered the federal government to release our client until he can be given a bond hearing. The government was unlawfully jailing him without the opportunity to seek release from an immigration judge – something he is entitled to under federal law.

As you may remember, we filed an emergency petition on Thursday, September 18, for an Ecuadoran roofer. Federal agents unlawfully detained him without a warrant after local police investigating a minor car accident turned him over. The government whisked our client away to a remote U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) facility in Fort Fairfield. They did not allow him to have any contact with the outside world for nine days.

Within 24 hours of filing the case, a federal judge granted our request to block the government from transferring him out of state while the court considered our petition. This prevented the government from further separating him from his community and legal counsel. Now, our client is finally out of detention – as federal law requires.

CBP, ICE, and the U.S. Department of Justice must follow the law. They cannot arrest people who entered the country years ago between ports-of-entry without a warrant. These agencies cannot re-write law passed by Congress and deny bond hearings.

As this case moves forward, we’re still working with the ACLU of Massachusetts and other advocates on a class action lawsuit to vindicate the rights of other people in similar situations. We’ll keep you updated as these cases develop.

This case also shows why LD 1971 – which passed the Maine Legislature this year and will go into effect unless the governor vetoes it – is so important. Our client never would have been disappeared to a remote CBP facility if local police had not turned a minor traffic investigation into a federal case, turning him over to CBP. Turning our state and local police into immigration agents does not make any of us safer.

Read more about these cases here.

Date

Wednesday, October 1, 2025 - 1:00pm

Featured image

Yellow and blue CBP badge on green shirt

Show featured image

Hide banner image

Tweet Text

[node:title]

Share Image

Yellow and blue CBP badge on green shirt

Related issues

Immigrants' Rights

Show related content

Pinned related content

Menu parent dynamic listing

1776

Show PDF in viewer on page

Style

Standard with sidebar

Show list numbers

Pages

Subscribe to ACLU of Maine RSS