Smart Justice: 2016 Legislative Session in Review
We went into the second regular session of the 127th Legislature looking to build on the successes of last year, when we worked to ban the shackling of pregnant women in correctional custody and to reduce some first-time, low-level drug possession charges. We faced a governor that seems hell-bent on ramping up the failed law enforcement approach, while denying people access to the treatment and recovery services they need.
Today we can say we have made even more progress toward ending Maine’s overreliance on punishment and incarceration as a way to fix societal problems.
But our work is not done - last week we learned that Maine has the highest rate in New England of children with an incarcerated parent. Our punitive system continues to tear families apart, without making us safer. Something has got to give, and we believe our legislative efforts are part of the solution.
Below is a round-up of our priority bills and their outcomes:
LD 1554 "An Act To Resolve Inconsistencies in the Drug Laws"
Status: VICTORY! Became law on April 28 without the Governor’s signature
In 2015, the legislature passed LD 113, our bill to reduce some low-level, first-time drug possession offenses from felonies to misdemeanors. We have always argued that felony convictions actually make it harder for a person suffering from substance use disorder to recover, by putting in place barriers to education, employment and housing.
This win was a huge success for drug law reform and a step toward ending our reliance on law enforcement to fix the drug problem. However, the legislature also passed LD 1246, which amended the same section of Maine law dealing with drug possession penalties. This created a conflict in the law.
LD 1554 was the Attorney General’s proposal to resolve the conflict, by essentially repealing LD 113. We opposed the original version of LD 1554, because it would have re-felonized the charges, rolling back the progress we made last year. The Criminal Justice Committee gave the bill an initial supportive vote of 9-4. The minority report, supported by four members, preserved misdemeanor charges for first-time, low-level possession with subsequent felony charges.
We lobbied hard to flip the vote on the floor of the Senate and the House, with the AG working hard on the other side. Going into the fight, we expected to lose the Senate but win the House, which would have killed the bill and given us the chance to fight again next session. We did indeed lose the Senate, but by just one vote – a much closer margin than we expected. Moving on to the House, we lobbied nearly every representative individually. Our work paid off – we won the House by a wide margin (83-63). The bill then moved back to the Senate, where we hoped to pick up the votes needed to put the bill on the governor’s desk.
Meanwhile, the governor’s staff joined the AG in trying to pick off enough votes in the House to get the majority report passed. Fortunately, most House members were locked in, agreeing with us that low-level possession should be treated as a misdemeanor. The AG then proposed a compromise – that low-level (below a certain threshold) possession would always be a misdemeanor offense, not just the first offense. The threshold (200mg) was lower than we would have liked –but not an unreasonable level. And a “forever misdemeanor” would mean that many Mainers suffering from substance use disorders would never have to face a felony record, and all the consequences that come with it. We agreed to support the compromise, which then sailed through the Senate with a vote of 35-0 and the House with a vote of 132-17, and with the support of the ACLU, the Attorney General, and bipartisan legislators.
A governor’s veto was a distinct possibility, and we were working to secure enough votes to override him. However, the governor let the 10-day window to veto pass and the bill became law last week without his signature.
LD 1639 "An Act To Implement the Recommendations of the Intergovernmental Pretrial Justice Reform Task Force"
Status: signed into law by the Governor on April 7, 2016
In the first session of the 127th Legislature, we proposed three criminal justice reform bills: a drug law reform bill (LD 113 - see above), a bill to ban the shackling of pregnant women (passed into law last year), and a bill to stop the jailing of people for being too poor to pay their fines (LD 951, sponsored by Rep. Mark Dion, D-Portland). We also supported a bail reform bill to overhaul Maine’s antiquated bail system.
We put together a comprehensive plan to end the jailing of people for being too poor to pay, which amounts to modern-day debtors’ prison. In addition to proposing legislation, we produced a study detailing the number of people in jail for failure to pay that led to a feature story in the Press Herald on the issue. The Press Herald and the Bangor Daily News also wrote editorials decrying the practice.
In the midst of this public attention, Chief Justice Saufley convened a task force to explore the issue of bail and fines reform in Maine. Our bill, LD 951, was tabled over the summer in anticipation of the task force recommendations. Alison was appointed to the task force, along with members of the judiciary, the legislature, the AG’s office, prosecutors, defense attorneys, victims’ advocates, and other stakeholders. Alison attended meeting after meeting throughout the summer and fall.
In December, the task force compiled a comprehensive report, complete with recommendations for reforms to ensure that indigent Mainers do not languish in jail under the weight of hefty fines and bail. The task force recommendations included specific language to give judges discretion to waive mandatory fines when individuals face financial hardship, thus ensuring poor Mainers don’t get caught up in the system.
The Judiciary Committee unanimously voted to turn the task force recommendations into a bill, LD 1639 (sponsored by committee chair Sen. David Burns, R-Whiting). In a rare moment, the AG, Governor, and ACLU of Maine all testified in favor of the same bill – a first (and probably last) in my time at the ACLU. The committee voted unanimously to adopt the task force recommendations almost wholesale (a few provisions that would have generated a fiscal noted were moved into further study and will hopefully pass next session). The bill sailed through the House and Senate and was signed by the governor.
LD 1577 "An Act To Increase the Availability of Mental Health Services"
Status: passed by the Legislature, died on the appropriations table
Since problems at Riverview came to light a few years ago, the Department of Health and Human Services has repeatedly demanded that the Legislature grant Commissioner Mayhew the authority to transfer forensic mental health patients to prison and jail units. Each time, the ACLU of Maine has loudly opposed these efforts.
The 2016 session was no different. A Governor’s bill, LD 1577 (sponsored by Rep. Deborah Sanderson, R-Chelsea), again proposed to put patients convicted of no crime (individuals deemed not criminally responsible and incompetent to stand trial) in prison. The Health and Human Services Committee vote was down party lines, with six Republican members supporting the governor’s bill and seven Democrats voting for an amended version of the bill to clarify that the Commissioner has no authority to transfer patients to jail settings. The amended version became the majority report, which we supported.
In close votes, the House and the Senate passed the majority report (to keep patients in hospital settings). That bill then went to the Appropriations Committee, where it remained until session adjourned - the bill "died on the table," meaning it will not become law. Because neither the original nor the amended version of the bill became law, the status quo remains the law of the land. DHHS still does not have the authority to transfer people in their custody, who have not been convicted of a crime, to prison.
From Our Blog
LD 1554 became law today without the signature of the governor. The law makes possession of heroin and other drugs a misdemeanor rather than a felony. Both houses of the Legislature voted overwhelmingly in favor of the bill.
The final version of LD 1554 ...more
Yesterday, the Bangor Daily News ran a helpful update on the status of efforts in the Legislature to change Maine's approach to drug use. We're thankful the Legislature recognizes the value of treatment over jail, even if the governor doesn't.
Gov. Paul LePage says he’s given...more
Earlier this month, Gov. LePage signed LD 1639, “An Act to Implement the Recommendations of the Intergovernmental Pretrial Justice Task Force,” into law. The ACLU of Maine supported the bill, which will improve Maine’s pretrial system by making reforms to the bail system and the imposition of ...more