Legal Director Carol Garvan

Carol Garvan

Legal Director

she/her

Over the past few months, we have been in court fighting back on multiple fronts to defend civil rights and liberties. From protecting voting rights and free speech to defending immigrants and birthright citizenship, here are some key updates from the past few weeks:

Voting Rights

U.S. v. Bellows: Last week, we filed an amicus brief urging a federal appeals court to reject the Trump administration's attempt to access sensitive Maine voter data, which could be used to build a national voter database and disenfranchise voters. We already won this argument at the trial court, and we hope the appeals court stops this attempted overreach once and for all.

Freedom of Speech

McGonigle v. Curran: In July, we sued the government after our client, social media influencer @CatsOnACouch, was barred from an official vice-presidential event in Bangor simply because she criticizes Vice President Vance online. The government cannot punish people for mocking those in power. This month, we made significant progress in the case by getting the government to allow Amanda to attend the vice president's Brewer event.

Birthright Citizenship

Barbara v. Trump: We're back in court defending birthright citizenship from the Trump administration's ongoing attacks. After our Supreme Court victory in June, the president signed another executive order targeting birthright citizenship. The 14th Amendment is still the law of the land, and we'll keep fighting to protect it.

Immigrants' Rights

Guerrero Orellana v. Moniz: A federal appeals court ruled this month in our favor, holding that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) cannot indefinitely jail people arrested in Maine, New Hampshire, or Massachusetts and deny them a bond hearing. Denying people a chance to seek freedom during immigration proceedings is not only cruel, it's against the plain language of federal law.

Academic Freedom

AAUP v. Rubio and Harvard v. HHS: The federal government is attempting an ideological takeover of academic institutions by targeting students, faculty, and organizations. We filed amicus briefs in two cases defending the First Amendment and academic freedom on college campuses. The government cannot use its power to punish or control people and institutions simply because it disagrees with their views.

Religious Liberty & LGBTQ Equality

Crosspoint Church v. Makin and St. Dom v. Makin: A federal appeals court recently ruled in our favor, holding that private schools participating in publicly funded programs are not exempt from the Maine Human Rights Act's ban on discrimination against students based on sexual orientation or gender identity. All schools that participate in state-funded programs must all play by the same rules.


This is just a snapshot of the work we're doing to hold those in power accountable and defend the civil rights and liberties of Maine people. We're also ramping up our election safeguarding work to keep Maine's elections free, safe, and fair. We'll share more about that soon so you can make your voice heard at the ballot box.

Thank you for standing with us in the fight to defend civil rights and liberties in Maine and beyond. We could not do it without your support.

Related Content


Initiative
Sep 2026
Defending Our Vote
  • Voting Rights

Defending Our Vote & Safeguarding Maine Elections

Voting is the best way to exercise your political power – no matter which candidates, causes, or parties you support. Your vote is your voice and your power, and the world needs to hear it!
Campaign
Sep 2026
Collage banner image
  • Immigrants' Rights

Protecting Birthright Citizenship at the Supreme Court

President Trump has targeted immigrants since his first day in office, and his efforts to eliminate birthright citizenship are at the center of his cruel agenda to redefine who gets to be an American. But the 14th Amendment guarantees citizenship to children born in the United States — and President Trump is not above the Constitution.
Court Case
Aug 11, 2026
A demonstrator looks up at her sign (which reads "Citizenship is a Birthright") during a rally outside the Supreme court building demanding the court uphold the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.
  • Immigrants' Rights

Barbara v. Trump – Class Action to Protect Birthright Citizenship

We sued the Trump administration for trying to end birthright citizenship, a core American principle that is outlined in the plain language of the 14th Amendment. The case was argued before the U.S. Supreme Court on April 1, 2026. On June 30, 2026, we won.
Court Case
Aug 25, 2026
An individuals holding a sign saying "Voting Rights Are For People Not Parties," outside of the U.S. Supreme Court ahead of arguments in the Voting Rights case Callais v. Landry.
  • Voting Rights|
  • +1 Issue

United States v. Bellows – Protecting Sensitive Voter Data

We're challenging the federal government’s attempt to access Maine’s unredacted voter file – including information like voters’ Social Security and driver’s license numbers.